Why Are Monthly Income Plans (MIPs) Better Than Annuity Products?

For anyone approaching retirement, the need for a reliable income stream becomes a top priority. 
But with so many products claiming to offer "guaranteed income," how do you decide what really works? One of the most common comparisons today is the monthly income plan vs annuity debate. 

While annuities have long been seen as a go-to solution for regular payouts, Monthly Income Plans (MIPs) have emerged as more flexible, transparent, and often better-performing alternatives in today’s dynamic financial industry.

Let’s explore why MIP is better than annuity products for retirement income, and how they can help you create a better post-retirement strategy.

Invest in Indian Markets and Unlock Future Potential With 5paisa!

Open Account Now

What Is a Monthly Income Plan and How Does It Compare to Annuities?

A Monthly Income Plan is a type of debt-oriented mutual fund plan that aims to offer regular income through a mix of debt and equity exposure. Despite its name, an MIP doesn’t guarantee monthly returns but can be structured for systematic withdrawals.
An annuity, on the other hand, is an insurance product that offers fixed periodic payouts, typically after you’ve invested a lump sum. It’s a predictable income source but often comes with less flexibility, lower returns, and higher tax implications.

The MIP vs annuity comparison becomes particularly relevant for retirees who seek control over their investments, inflation protection, and better returns.

Monthly Income Plan Benefits Over Annuities

Here’s what sets MIPs apart:

• Liquidity and Access: MIPs offer higher liquidity. You can withdraw partially or fully as needed, unlike annuities where money gets locked in.
• Inflation Hedge: With some equity allocation, MIPs offer inflation hedging investment potential, whereas annuities offer fixed payouts that lose value over time.
• Tax Efficiency: Through indexation, capital gains tax MIP is lower compared to fully taxable annuity income.
• Returns Potential: Historically, MIP returns vs fixed deposits or annuity returns have been better, especially when markets are stable.

Advantages of MIPs Compared to Annuities

With rising inflation and evolving financial instruments, annuities are losing ground as the default retirement option. Here’s why MIPs are shining brighter in today’s scenario:

• Equity Exposure in Retirement Plan: Even a 10–25% equity allocation in a debt–equity hybrid fund can enhance long-term gains without drastically increasing risk.
• Systematic Withdrawal Plan (SWP): This feature lets you customise your income flow in an MIP, offering more flexibility than fixed annuity payouts.
• Non-Insurance Retirement Income Options: MIPs are non-insurance investment vehicles, which means no commission cuts or lock-ins associated with insurance-linked annuities.

How Monthly Income Plans Yield More Than Fixed Annuities?

Unlike annuities that promise fixed returns (often 5–6% p.a.), MIPs can yield 7–10% annually depending on market conditions. This performance edge is attributed to:

• Active fund management
• Equity exposure
• Lower operational costs

Additionally, monthly dividend mutual funds within MIPs offer the potential for both capital appreciation and regular payouts.

Monthly Income Plans Inflation Protection vs Annuities

One of the critical shortcomings of annuity products is their inability to grow with inflation. With MIPs, even a modest equity component ensures that your capital keeps pace or outpaces inflation, making it a better fit for long-term post-retirement income planning.
In contrast, a fixed annuity locks your payout, gradually eroding purchasing power over a 20-year retirement horizon.

Types of Monthly Income Mutual Funds in India

The Indian market offers a wide variety of MIP options customised for retirees:

• Conservative Hybrid Funds: Low-risk investments for senior citizens.
• Aggressive Hybrid Funds: For those with a moderate risk appetite.
• Fixed Income Mutual Fund Plans: With minimal equity, focusing on predictable returns.

These are excellent alternatives to annuity plans and are among the best monthly income plans in India.

How to Invest in MIPs?: A Quick Guide

• Choose a fund with a strong track record and low expense ratio.
• Decide your withdrawal strategy using the SWP route.
• Consult a financial advisor to align MIP choices with your retirement goals.

Always remember: the debt allocation in MIP should align with your risk tolerance and income needs.

Final Thoughts

So, are MIPs better than annuities for regular income?

For most investors, especially retirees, the answer is a confident yes. MIPs combine flexibility, tax efficiency, and potentially higher returns, making them a superior choice in the monthly income plan vs annuity debate.

With evolving markets, rising inflation, and growing awareness about investment control, MIPs are no longer just a "mutual fund with regular payouts", they're strategic tools for smart retirement planning.

If you’re still deciding how to choose between an MIP and an annuity for retirement income, consider the following:

• Do you value liquidity?
• Are you looking for inflation protection?
• Do you prefer tax optimization?

If your answer to any of these is yes, then exploring income-oriented mutual funds like MIPs is not just smart, it’s necessary.