Nifty 50 Defies Trends, Moves in Sync with Volatility Index for Days

In an unusual development, India’s primary stock index and its volatility measure have moved in the same direction for seven consecutive days. This trend suggests that traders may be growing less concerned about further declines in large-cap stocks.

Invest in Indian Markets and Unlock Future Potential With 5paisa!

Open Account Now

Since its peak in September, the NSE Nifty 50 Index has dropped by 14% as investors have questioned the market’s high valuations, particularly with corporate earnings and economic growth showing signs of slowing. Recently, the India NSE Volatility Index has also declined, reflecting reduced demand for options speculating on movements in the benchmark index, which primarily consists of India's leading companies.

“The decline in hedging activity indicates an expectation of greater stability in large-cap stocks,” said Sonam Srivastava, founder and CEO of Wright Research in Mumbai. She noted that larger stocks may hold up better if the market continues to decline, adding that her firm recently shifted its hedging focus from the Nifty 50 to mid-cap stocks.

Mid-cap stocks and small-cap stocks have suffered steeper losses than the broader market since the Nifty 50's peak on September 26, with indices tracking these segments falling more than 18%. Although market sentiment has largely remained bearish, some investment firms have recently adopted a more optimistic stance.

This week, Citigroup Inc. upgraded its outlook on Indian equities from neutral to overweight, citing "significant upside potential" alongside "more reasonable" valuations. Earlier in the month, Invesco strategist David Chao highlighted Indian stocks as strong long-term structural investments, while Morgan Stanley predicted the market would regain its outperformance as India’s economic slowdown appears to be easing.

On Thursday, the India VIX continued its decline, while the Nifty 50 showed little movement. The last instance of both indices moving in the same direction for seven days was in September 2021, just before the equity index reached a peak it struggled to surpass for a year.

Historically, the Nifty 50 and India VIX have moved in the same direction about 30% to 40% of the time since the volatility index was introduced. In contrast, the S&P 500 Index and the Cboe Volatility Index in the U.S. tend to move in opposite directions approximately 80% of the time, with synchronized movements often signaling potential market risks.

While European markets exhibit similar behavior to the U.S., Hong Kong’s market dynamics differ. Recently, traders driving the rally have also fueled an increase in the local options price index. The Hang Seng Index and the HSI Volatility Index moved in tandem on a record 54% of trading days last year, with the proportion for 2025 already exceeding 60%.

Understanding the Market Implications

Market experts suggest that when an equity index and its volatility index rise together, it can indicate unusual market conditions. This phenomenon often suggests investors are adjusting their risk expectations, possibly in response to global cues, economic data, or corporate earnings reports.

In India's case, some analysts believe the synchronized movements between the Nifty 50 and India VIX reflect shifting investor sentiment rather than immediate economic distress. With corporate earnings season approaching, traders may be repositioning portfolios, anticipating either a stabilization in large-cap stocks or a shift in market leadership.

The Indian stock market has also been impacted by global factors, including U.S. Federal Reserve policy decisions, crude oil price fluctuations, and geopolitical developments. Foreign institutional investors (FIIs), who play a crucial role in market liquidity, have shown mixed participation recently, balancing between profit-booking and fresh inflows in selected sectors.

Another contributing factor is domestic investor behavior. Retail and mutual fund investments in large-cap stocks have remained steady, providing a cushion against sharp declines. The resilience of India’s banking and IT sectors has also helped maintain stability in the benchmark index.

Looking ahead, market participants will closely watch macroeconomic indicators, corporate earnings growth, and global market trends to assess whether the current trend is a temporary anomaly or a signal of broader market shifts.