Bank, Financial Stocks Tumble as IRDAI Flags High Insurance Payouts; Axis Bank, IDFC First Bank, Bajaj Finance Tank

Banking and financial services stocks came under pressure on Thursday, September 24, after the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI) raised concerns over the economics of insurance distribution through banks. 

Invest in Indian Markets and Unlock Future Potential With 5paisa!

Open Account Now

The regulator has questioned whether the remuneration paid to banks under multiple insurance tie-ups is proportionate to the work involved in selling and servicing policies, or whether part of it reflects the value insurers place on gaining access to a bank’s customer base. 

The concerns are part of IRDAI’s proposed overhaul of insurance distribution, with the regulator looking to place greater emphasis on affordability, customer value and long-term policyholder outcomes. 

The development weighed on banking and financial stocks in early trade, with several lenders and non-banking financial companies recording declines. 

AU Small Finance Bank falls around 5% 

AU Small Finance Bank was among the biggest losers, falling around 5%. IndusInd Bank, Axis Bank and IDFC First Bank declined around 4% each. 

Kotak Mahindra Bank, HDFC Bank, Bank of Baroda and State Bank of India were also down more than 1% each. 

The weakness was visible across the banking index. The Nifty Bank was down more than 1.5%, compared with declines of around 1% in the Sensex and Nifty 50. 

Financial services stocks faced similar pressure. The Nifty Financial Services index dropped 2%. 

Cholamandalam Investment, Bajaj Finance and Bajaj Finserv fell more than 3% each. HDFC AMC, Shriram Finance, Muthoot Finance, PFC and REC declined over 1% apiece. 

IRDAI examines payouts under bank-led insurance distribution 

IRDAI’s consultation paper has put the remuneration structure used in bank-led insurance distribution under scrutiny. 

According to the regulator’s analysis cited in the report, banks accounted for nearly ₹68,000 crore of corporate-agency life insurance premiums in the sample studied. 

The analysis found that payouts under multiple tie-up arrangements were considerably higher than those under single tie-ups. 

IRDAI raised the possibility that such remuneration may be influenced by competition among insurers seeking access to banking distribution networks, rather than being determined solely by the work required to sell and service insurance policies. 

Banks have extensive access to customers through their branch networks and lending relationships, making them an important distribution channel for insurance companies. 

Transparency around commissions also under review 

Another area highlighted by IRDAI is the level of transparency available to customers purchasing insurance through bank branches or loan desks. 

Customers may have limited visibility into the commissions included in insurance premiums and little control over the distribution costs attached to the products they are offered. 

According to the regulator, this can make it more difficult for customers to compare insurance products and can reduce competitive pressure on pricing. 

The proposed changes seek to address these concerns while changing the incentives within the distribution system. 

IRDAI proposes restrictions on compulsory insurance bundling 

Among the proposals under consideration is a ban on banks and non-banking financial companies from making the purchase of insurance compulsory when providing loans or other financial products. 

The proposed restriction would apply to insurance linked with home loans, motor loans and other forms of borrowing. 

IRDAI defines compulsory bundling as a situation where a borrower can obtain a loan only after purchasing an insurance policy covering areas such as life, property, motor or health. 

The proposal does not seek to discontinue bancassurance itself. 

Instead, the regulator wants customers to have greater control over insurance purchases, including easier comparison between products, more direct buying options and clearer information about insurers, products and distributors. 

IRDAI has also proposed public disclosure of expense and commission performance by insurers and large distributors. 

The consultation paper therefore places both distribution costs and selling practices under closer scrutiny. The immediate market reaction on September 24 was visible across banking and financial services stocks, with the Nifty Bank and Nifty Financial Services indices falling alongside declines in several major lenders and financial companies.