5 Common Mistakes to Avoid in ETF Trading in India

Over the past ten years, Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) have taken off in India, and it’s easy to see why. They’re flexible, cost-effective, and offer built-in diversification. Whether you’re just starting your investing journey or already know your way around the markets, ETFs can be a solid option. But here’s the catch: like any investment tool, they’re not foolproof.

Thanks to user-friendly platforms like 5paisa, more everyday investors are getting into ETF trading. But without fully understanding how ETFs work, it's easy to make mistakes that can eat into your returns or ramp up your risk. Whether you're a newbie or looking to up your game, avoiding common slip-ups is essential.

In this guide, we’ll break down five frequent ETF mistakes Indian investors make and how to avoid them so you can invest smarter and more confidently.

Invest in Indian Markets and Unlock Future Potential With 5paisa!

Open Account Now

1. Not Knowing What Your ETF Actually Tracks
All ETFs are not created equal. Many beginners think they are and end up picking funds based only on performance or hearsay.

What’s the risk?

You may be investing in a low-risk, broad-market fund. Still, you’ve picked a sector-specific or international ETF that's way more volatile—for example, Nifty 50 and Nifty Next 50 track very different companies. International ETFs, like those linked to the Nasdaq-100, carry currency and geopolitical risks you might not expect.

What to do instead:

• Always check the ETF’s factsheet, see what index it tracks and which stocks it holds.
• Look at sector and region exposure.
• Understand how the index is built: market cap-weighted, equal-weighted, or theme-based?
• Use sites like NSE India or AMFI to compare ETFs before investing.

2. Ignoring Liquidity and Bid-Ask Spreads
In India, not all ETFs trade frequently, some have very low volumes.

What’s the risk?

ETFs trade like stocks, so if an ETF doesn’t have enough buyers and sellers, you might have to pay more to buy or settle for less when selling. This gap, the bid-ask spread, can quietly eat into your returns.

How to fix it:

• Check the ETF’s daily trading volume.
• Look at how tight or wide the bid-ask spread is.
• Use limit orders (instead of market orders) to set your buying/selling price.
• Try to trade during high-volume hours, 10:00 a.m. to 2:30 p.m. is often ideal.

3. Overlooking Tracking Error and Expense Ratio
ETFs are meant to mimic an index, but they don’t always do it perfectly.

What’s the risk?

If an ETF has a high tracking error, its returns are drifting away from the index it follows. Add a high expense ratio, and you’re losing money to management fees and inefficiency. In India, some ETFs claim to be “low-cost” but still miss the mark due to poor execution or low AUM (Assets Under Management).

Your checklist:

• Compare tracking errors between ETFs tracking the same index.
• Pick funds with low expense ratios AND low tracking error.
• Favor ETFs with higher AUM, they usually run more smoothly.
• Use sites like Morningstar India or Value Research Online to check stats.

4. Forgetting About Taxes
This one’s easy to miss. Tax rules for ETFs in India vary depending on whether the ETF is equity- or debt-based, and how long you hold it.

What’s the risk?

Say you invest in a debt ETF thinking it’s taxed like equity. You could end up with a bigger tax bill than expected. Also, dividends are taxed at your income tax rate.

How to stay tax-smart:

• Confirm if your ETF is equity or debt-oriented.
• Plan your holding period to minimise tax outgo.
• Don’t forget to factor in taxes when estimating returns.
• When in doubt, talk to a tax advisor.

5. Trading Too Often Without a Clear Strategy
ETFs are flexible, yes. But that doesn’t mean they’re built for constant back-and-forth trading.

What’s the risk?

Frequent trades rack up costs, brokerage fees, taxes, and stamp duties, which chip away at profits. Worse, many investors make snap decisions without a strategy based on emotions, not data. It becomes more like gambling than investing.

How to stay on track:

• Use ETFs mainly for long-term goals.
• If you’re trading short-term, use technical or fundamental analysis to guide your moves.
• Factor in transaction costs every time.
• Don’t chase trends, stick to a plan or consider using SIPs in ETFs for disciplined investing.

Final Thoughts: Smarter ETF Trading = Better Results

ETFs can be a great tool to grow your wealth. But just like any tool, it’s all about how you use it.
To recap, avoid these five mistakes:

• Don’t ignore what’s inside the ETF.
• Check liquidity and watch out for bid-ask spreads.
• Keep an eye on tracking errors and expenses.
• Understand how taxes will affect your gains.
• Trade with a plan, or better yet, invest with purpose.

With the proper research and mindset, ETFs can give you efficient, low-cost exposure to Indian and global markets. The key is to stay informed and intentional. Because when it comes to investing, clarity beats chaos every time.