WhiteOak Capital Study Finds Slow-Starting SIPs Recorded Higher Average 10-Year Returns
Last Updated: 19th November 2026 - 01:52 pm
Key Takeaways
- A WhiteOak Capital study examined historical SIP returns using the BSE Sensex Total Return Index between August 1996 and October 2026.
- SIP periods with annualised returns of 8% or less during the first five years recorded an average 10-year return of 18.3%.
- Periods with first-five-year returns above 8% recorded an average 10-year return of 14.6%, illustrating how historical return patterns varied with market conditions.
A historical study by WhiteOak Capital Mutual Fund has found that systematic investment plans recording relatively weak returns during their first five years subsequently delivered higher average returns over a full ten-year period in the examined dataset.
The research used historical observations from the BSE Sensex Total Return Index between August 1996 and October 2026.
According to the findings reported by Moneycontrol on 19 November, SIP periods that generated annualised returns of 8% or less over their first five years recorded an average annualised return of 18.3% over ten years.
By comparison, SIP periods with first-five-year returns above 8% recorded an average ten-year return of 14.6%.
The study describes historical outcomes within a specific index dataset. It does not establish that lower initial returns will necessarily result in stronger future performance.
What the SIP Return Study Found
| Historical SIP grouping | Average annualised return over 10 years |
|---|---|
| First 5-year return of 8% or less | 18.3% |
| First 5-year return above 8% | 14.6% |
Source: WhiteOak Capital study, as reported by Moneycontrol. Figures are historical group averages.
The difference between the two groups was 3.7 percentage points.
The comparison uses a fixed first-five-year return threshold and examines subsequent outcomes over the complete ten-year investment period.
It should not be interpreted as a comparison between two different mutual fund schemes.
How Market Cycles Influence SIP Outcomes
SIPs involve investing fixed amounts at recurring intervals.
The number of units accumulated during each instalment depends on the asset's value at that point.
When prices decline, the same contribution can purchase more units. If the underlying index subsequently recovers, those accumulated units participate in the later market increase.
This mechanism may help explain why some historically weak initial periods were followed by stronger longer-term outcomes.
However, the relationship depends on the depth of market declines, the timing of recovery and the duration of the investment period.
A prolonged downturn or weak subsequent performance can produce a different result.
Longer Holding Periods and Negative Return Observations
The WhiteOak study also examined how frequently historical SIP periods delivered positive returns over different durations.
The findings reported by Moneycontrol showed that approximately 92% of five-year SIP periods generated positive returns.
All eight-year and ten-year SIP periods examined in the study recorded positive outcomes.
These findings relate to the historical sample and the particular index analysed.
They are not a guarantee that future SIPs held for eight or ten years will avoid losses.
Understanding the Return Metric
The analysis concerns recurring contributions rather than one-time lump-sum investments.
SIP performance is generally measured using money-weighted annualised returns, commonly expressed through the extended internal rate of return, or XIRR, methodology.
A SIP return therefore cannot be compared directly with a lump-sum compound annual growth rate without accounting for the different timing of cash flows.
The study also used a total return index, which incorporates dividends into the underlying index calculation.
Its historical observations should not be presented as the actual returns of a particular mutual fund scheme.
The research provides a quantitative illustration of how the sequence of market movements can affect long-term SIP outcomes.
- 0 Transaction Cost
- Curated Fund Lists
- 4000+ MF Schemes
- Start SIP with Ease
Trending on 5paisa
Disclaimer: Investment in securities market are subject to market risks, read all the related documents carefully before investing. For detailed disclaimer please Click here.