Atal Pension Yojana vs NPS: Which is Better for Low-Income Investors?

Planning for retirement can feel overwhelming, especially if you’re earning a modest income and don’t have access to an employer-provided pension schemes. In India, the government has introduced two schemes to help secure your future: the Atal Pension Yojana (APY) and the National Pension System (NPS). Both aim to ensure financial stability in later years, but they work quite differently. So, which one is better for low-income investors? 

Invest in Indian Markets and Unlock Future Potential With 5paisa!

Open Account Now

Understanding the Atal Pension Yojana (APY)   

Launched in 2015, APY is designed for people in the unorganised sector – such as small shop owners, domestic workers, or daily wage earners. Its main attraction is a fixed monthly pension that ranges from ₹1,000 to ₹5,000, depending on your contribution and age at the time of joining. 

The scheme is simple and easy to understand. You pick your desired pension and your age, and APY tells you exactly how much you need to contribute each month. Contributions are manageable even for those with limited income. 

Other features of APY include: 

• Government guarantee: The pension amount is guaranteed by the government, providing financial security and peace of mind. 
• Family benefits: If the subscriber passes away, the spouse continues to receive the pension. The accumulated corpus goes to the nominee after both have passed. 
• Tax benefits: Contributions are eligible for deductions under Section 80CCD(1). 

Eligibility criteria: 

• Age between 18 and 40 years 
• Must have a savings account linked to Aadhaar 
• Income tax payers are not eligible 

For low-income earners, APY offers security and predictability, which is often the most important factor when planning for retirement. 

Exploring the National Pension System (NPS)   

The National Pension System, introduced in 2004, takes a different approach. NPS is open to all Indian citizens between 18 and 70 years old, and it’s designed to be flexible and investment-oriented. 

Unlike APY, NPS does not provide a fixed pension. The amount you receive at retirement depends on how much you contribute and how well your investments perform. You can choose to invest in government bonds, corporate bonds, or equities, which gives you the potential for higher returns but also introduces market risk. 

Key features of NPS: 

Flexible contributions according to your budget 

Two account types: 

• Tier I: Main pension account with limited withdrawal options 
• Tier II: Voluntary savings account with easier access 

Tax benefits: Contributions up to ₹1.5 lakh qualify under Section 80C, with an additional ₹50,000 under Section 80CCD(1B) 

NPS is suitable for those who understand investment risks and want to actively manage their retirement savings. However, for someone who prefers stability, the variable returns may feel uncertain. 

APY vs NPS for Low-Income Investors   

When deciding between APY and NPS, the key question is whether you prefer certainty or potential growth. 

For low-income individuals, APY is often the safer choice: 

• It guarantees a fixed pension backed by the government. 
• Contributions are small, easy to manage, and predictable. 
• It provides a sense of financial security without the stress of market fluctuations. 

NPS, on the other hand, offers flexibility and the chance for higher returns, but with added risk. Market-linked returns mean your pension can fluctuate, which may not be ideal for someone relying on a steady income post-retirement. 

Which One Should You Choose?   

For low-income investors, APY generally emerges as the better choice because it ensures financial security with minimal complexity. The fixed pension amount and government backing provide peace of mind, while modest monthly contributions make the scheme accessible. 

However, if an individual has some capacity to invest, a basic understanding of the market, and a long-term outlook, NPS can be considered for potential higher returns. It is also suitable for individuals who want to combine retirement savings with other investment strategies, leveraging market performance to build a larger corpus over time. 

Ultimately, the best pension plan in India for a low-income individual depends on personal circumstances. Assessing financial goals, risk tolerance, and retirement needs is crucial before making a decision. Speaking with a financial advisor can also help tailor the choice to one’s specific situation, ensuring a more secure and comfortable retirement.