Buyback of Shares: Key Advantages and Disadvantages Explained

People often hear the term “buyback” on business news and wonder what it actually means. The buyback of shares meaning is pretty simple: a company purchases its own shares from the market or directly from its shareholders. That’s it. Nothing fancy. But the conversation around it becomes complicated because it affects investors differently. And that’s why understanding the advantages and disadvantages of buyback of shares matters.

Let us share detailed insights in a simple and an easy to understand manner.

When a company starts a buyback, it signals that management believes the share price should be higher than what the market currently thinks. Some investors take that as a vote of confidence. One more thing, fewer shares in the market usually means the earnings per share figure goes up. Even when profits stay the same, EPS looks cleaner. This is one of the big pros of share buyback, and it’s why people get excited whenever a big company announces one.

Invest in Indian Markets and Unlock Future Potential With 5paisa!

Open Account Now

There’s also the flexibility angle. Dividends feel more like a commitment. Once a company starts paying them, people expect them regularly. Buybacks aren’t like that. They can be done once, skipped, done later, whenever the company feels it’s the right time. So for management, buybacks give more freedom.

But of course, there are downsides. Sometimes a buyback looks like a shortcut, a way to make numbers look prettier without improving real business performance. And then there’s the debt issue. A few companies borrow money just to buy back their own shares. It may boost things for a while, but long-term it can backfire. This is one of the biggest disadvantages of buyback of shares, and analysts bring it up all the time.

Another point people forget is opportunity cost. If a company uses a huge chunk of money for a buyback, it can’t use that same money for research, expansion, new product development, or clearing old debts. That’s where the “should they have used the money better?” debate comes in.

Talking about the different categories of share buyback, two of them are main ones. Open-market buyback is a casual one, that is, the company purchases stocks gradually whenever the price is just right. Then, there is the tender offer where the company provides a predetermined price to the shareholders and requests them to sell within a stipulated time. Tender offers usually grab more notice as the price is occasionally somewhat above the market price.

At the end of the day, whether a buyback is good or not depends entirely on why the company is doing it. Sometimes it’s a smart move; sometimes it’s just an attempt to make numbers look better. Investors shouldn’t panic or celebrate too quickly. Just look at the intention behind the announcement, the company’s financial health, and how the buyback fits into their long-term plan.