Open-Ended Vs Closed-Ended Mutual Fund Schemes

When navigating the complex world of mutual funds in India, one of the first decisions investors encounter is choosing between open-ended and closed-end mutual funds. At first glance, both offer access to professionally managed portfolios, but their structure, flexibility, and potential benefits differ substantially.

Understanding the difference between open-ended and closed-ended mutual funds isn’t just a technical detail; it’s a crucial step in shaping your overall investment strategy in mutual funds. Let’s understand these two popular types of mutual funds in India.

Invest in Indian Markets and Unlock Future Potential With 5paisa!

Open Account Now

What Are Open-Ended Mutual Funds?

Open-ended mutual funds are schemes that allow investors to enter and exit at any time, based on the prevailing Net Asset Value (NAV) of the mutual fund. These funds are designed for flexibility, offering high liquidity and convenience to investors.

Open-Ended Fund Features:

• No fixed maturity period – You can stay invested as long as you wish.
• Daily liquidity – Investors can redeem or purchase units on any business day.
• NAV-based trading – Units are bought/sold based on the NAV calculated at the end of the day.
• Best suited for – Those seeking liquidity, flexibility, and long-term capital appreciation.

Because of the open-ended mutual fund liquidity explained above, these are generally considered ideal for SIP investors or anyone building wealth over time.

What Are Closed-End Mutual Funds?

On the other hand, close-ended mutual funds have a fixed maturity period and are only open for subscription during a New Fund Offer (NFO) period. Once this window closes, no new investors will be able to enter.

Closed-Ended Fund Structure:

• Fixed lock-in period – Typically ranges from 3 to 5 years.
• Traded on stock exchanges – After the NFO, units can be bought/sold in the secondary market trading of mutual funds.
• NAV and market price may differ – Often traded at a premium or discount to NAV.
• Ideal for disciplined investors – Investors who can stay invested until the closed-ended mutual fund's maturity.

Want to know what happens when a closed-ended fund matures? Upon maturity, proceeds are paid out to investors, or the fund may be rolled over for another term.

Open vs Closed-Ended Mutual Fund: Key Differences

Let’s simplify the comparison of mutual fund types with a practical breakdown. 
Open-ended funds allow subscription at any time and offer high liquidity through the fund house. They do not have a fixed maturity period, and trading is based on NAV. These are ideal for investors seeking long-term, flexible investment options. 

In contrast, close-ended funds are available only during the NFO period and have limited liquidity as they can be traded only on stock exchanges. They come with a fixed term, and their market-driven prices may vary from NAV. These funds are better suited for those with a locked-in, disciplined investment style.

How do you choose between open and closed-ended funds? It depends on your goals, risk tolerance, and need for liquidity.

Pros and Cons: Open-Ended vs Closed-Ended Returns

Advantages of Open-Ended Mutual Funds for Beginners:

• Flexibility in investing and redeeming.
• Suitable for SIPs and long-term goals.
• Transparent mutual fund redemption process.

Advantages of Closed-Ended Mutual Funds

• Lock-in can enforce disciplined investing.
• Fund managers are not pressured by redemptions.
• May offer good opportunities during NFO if the market conditions are favourable.

However, open-ended vs closed-ended returns can vary widely depending on market timing, fund category, and investor behaviour.

Tax Implications of Closed-End Mutual Funds

From a tax standpoint, the tax implications of closed-end mutual funds are broadly similar to those of open-ended schemes. Capital gains tax depends on the type of fund (equity or debt) and holding period. Do note that premature selling on stock exchanges may result in capital gains tax.

Mutual Fund Liquidity Options & Redemption Cycles

If you're focused on liquidity, open-ended schemes win. About the redemption cycle, open-ended funds typically allow withdrawals within 1–3 working days. In contrast, while you can redeem closed-ended mutual funds early by selling them in the market, liquidity and price discovery can be challenging.

Exit load in close-ended mutual fund schemes is rare, given the lock-in period; however, it’s wise to check the Scheme Information Document (SID).

Factors to Consider When Choosing Between Fund Types

Here’s a checklist:

• Financial Goals: Open-ended for goals needing liquidity; close-ended for long-term planning.
• Market Timing Confidence: If you can accurately time the markets, close-ended NFOs may be a suitable option for you.
• Fund Manager Role in Mutual Funds: In closed-ended schemes, fund managers often have more freedom to implement strategies without facing redemption pressures.
• NAV vs. Market Price Awareness: Be aware that the net asset value (NAV) versus market price may vary in closed-ended funds.

Looking for the best open vs closed-end mutual fund for long‑term investment? Consider consistency, AMC credibility, expense ratio, and past returns over gimmicky performance.

Final Thoughts: Which One Should You Choose?

So, what is the key difference between open-ended and closed-ended funds? It boils down to flexibility, liquidity, and investment style.

Go for open-ended schemes in mutual funds if you want liquidity, SIP benefits, and ease of entry/exit.
Opt for closed-ended mutual funds if you’re okay with a lock-in and want to avoid emotional exits during volatility.

Whether you’re an experienced investor or just starting out, understanding these fund types will equip you to make informed, confident decisions. So next time you’re comparing options, don’t just look at returns, evaluate the fund's NAV calculation, maturity period of mutual funds, and how the expense ratio of the mutual fund might impact you.