One in Five Nifty 50 Stocks Deliver Flat to Negative Returns Over Three Years

Nearly 20% of Nifty 50 stocks have posted flat to negative returns over the past three years on a compound annual growth rate basis ending January 19. This underperformance hits several heavyweight companies even as the broader index surges and mutual funds boost their stakes.

Data reveals slowing growth in mature businesses and weak earnings momentum as key drags. Many of these firms remain among India's most valued, yet lag behind simpler options like state-run bank fixed deposits.

According to data released by Nifty Fifty, nearly twenty per cent of all stocks on that index have demonstrated flat or negative overall returns for the last three years as measured by Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) through January 19; this trend has affected many high-market-value companies even as the market itself has continued its upward trajectory and more and more mutual funds are investing more into their stocks.

Invest in Indian Markets and Unlock Future Potential With 5paisa!

Open Account Now

Underperforming Heavyweights Exposed

Tata Consultancy Services (TCS), which is India’s largest IT services company, has an average negative CAGR return of 2.1% over three years. In comparison, Infosys, which is the second largest IT services company in India, shows a CAGR increase of approximately 3%, while Hindustan Unilever shows a negative CAGR return of roughly 3%.
Reliance Industries, which has the largest market capitalisation in India, has grown at a CAGR of approximately 4.6% over three years. HDFC Bank, India’s largest bank by market capitalisation, has had an average return over the last three years of only 4%. These three underperformers illustrate some of the difficulties faced by three major industries, which are IT, banking, and consumer goods industries.

Banking and Conglomerate Struggles

Kotak Mahindra Bank has gained about 6.5% in this same six-month period; Adani Enterprises, however, has had major losses of nearly 14%.
The largest cigarette manufacturer in India, ITC, has shown essentially flat returns for this period, while Asian Paints has fallen by about 1.3%, and Tata Motors Passenger Vehicles has declined by about 5%. Factors, including increased competition and weaker demand, have impacted all of these companies' performance negatively.

Reasons Behind the Lags and Investor Lessons

Mutual funds have increased their investment in these stocks despite their poor performance, in anticipation of future growth. Unfortunately, since many of these companies have already shown sustained failures to improve financials, their possible future earnings are unlikely to be anywhere near their historical highs.
The Nifty 50 index itself provides an overall view of the strength of India, but under it, there are pockets of stagnant growth for some sectors. As the market continues to mature, the data ending January 19, highlights the importance of stock selection and its relationship with mega-caps during periods when large indices are in actual bullish mode. The next big indicators for these various companies will be their upcoming quarterly reports.