Difference Between GST and VAT
5paisa Research Team
Last Updated: 12 Nov, 2024 04:43 PM IST
Want to start your Investment Journey?
Content
- What is a Goods and Service Tax (GST)
- What is a Value Added Tax (VAT)
- Differences Between GST and VAT
- Calculations of GST and VAT
- Conclusion
The Indian government introduced the Goods and Services Tax (GST) to streamline taxes on goods and services, aiming for a progressive economy. GST consolidated various individual taxes previously borne by consumers into one uniform tax. It replaced taxes such as service tax and excise duty. Although GST overshadowed many taxes, certain taxes like VAT on goods still persist. Understanding the distinction between VAT and GST is crucial for consumers to recognize the indirect taxes they may incur.
What is a Goods and Service Tax (GST)
GST and VAT differ in their scope and implementation. GST, introduced in India, aims to unify the taxation system for goods and services nationwide. Unlike VAT, GST doesn't apply to IPO subscriptions. It operates as a value-added tax on products and services consumed daily, levied on consumers and remitted by sellers to the Indian government. While GST is lauded for its equitable tax structure, critics argue it burdens all taxpayers indiscriminately. Notably, GST excludes certain items like alcoholic beverages, petroleum, and tobacco. GST functions as a destination-based consumption tax, accruing revenue to the state of consumption. Implemented in 2017, GST replaced various central and state indirect taxes, including VAT, excise duty, and service tax, mitigating the cascading effect of taxes in the economy.
What is a Value Added Tax (VAT)
Value Added Tax (VAT) was integrated into India's tax system on April 1, 2005, replacing Sales Tax. It aimed to unify India's market. Implemented nationwide by June 2, 2014, VAT operates similarly to GST as an indirect tax remitted to the Indian government. However, unlike GST, VAT applies within states, not centrally. Manufacturers pay VAT at each stage of production, contributing to the product's value chain. VAT varies across states, applied to different goods and services, unlike GST's uniformity. For interstate transactions, Central Sales Tax (CST) was applicable, levied by the Central Government and collected by states.
Differences Between GST and VAT
Key Differences Between GST and VAT
|
VAT | GST |
Commencement | 2005 | 2017 |
Regulations and Rates of Taxation |
VAT rates vary by state and product category. Each state applies its own tax rules. |
GST has a uniform rate across India. Different GST acts apply to various transactions. |
Regulatory Authority | State government governs VAT for each state. | Both State GST and Central GST are collected, then divided between the central and state governments. |
Compliance | Compliance varies by state for goods movement. | GST compliance is uniform nationwide for goods movement. |
Collection of Tax | Tax collection responsibility lies with the seller's state. | Tax collection responsibility lies with the state where goods and services are consumed. |
|
Old VAT/Indirect Tax System | New GST Model |
Nature of Tax | Based on Origin or value addition | Destination-based tax on final consumption |
Central Taxes Subsumed | Central Excise Additional Duty of Customs Service Tax | CGST |
State Taxes Subsumed | VAT Purchase Tax Entertainment Tax Luxury Tax Lottery Taxes State Cess and Surcharge Entry Tax | SGST |
Custom Duties Replaced | Basic custom duty Additional Duty of Customs Special Additional Duty of Customs Cess | BCD IGST |
Inter State Taxes Replaced | Excise Duty Central Sales Tax Service Tax | IGST |
Intra State Taxes Replaced | Excise Duty State VAT Service Tax | CGST SGST |
Taxation event | Tax is levied on manufacture, sale/completion of provision of services | Supply of Goods and Services |
|
Old VAT/Indirect Tax System | New GST Model |
Taxation Point | Sale of Goods | Supply of Goods and Services |
Applicability | On goods only | Both Goods and Services |
Registration Threshold | Compulsory if turnover exceeds Rs 10 lakhs | Compulsory if turnover exceeds Rs 40 lakhs |
Collection of revenue | By selling state | GST is destination or consumption-based tax |
Interstate tax credit | Not available (CENVAT applicable) | Can be taken |
Compliances required | Multiple compliances and registrations | Compliance procedure has been streamlined |
Cascading effect | VAT was levied on value addition at each stage | The ill of Tax on Tax has been eradicated |
Online Payment | Online tax payment was not mandatory | It is necessary to make online payment of GST |
Considerable Differences:
● GST offers a more convenient tax application method compared to VAT. However, VAT is still applicable to certain goods like liquor and cigarettes not covered by GST.
● For investors, taxes may not apply to profits made through a demat account or upcoming IPO investments, but intraday transactions in trading are subject to GST.
Calculations of GST and VAT
Under GST (Goods and Services Tax):
● GST Calculation:
● Output Tax: Tax collected on sales (output supplies).
● Input Tax: Tax paid on purchases (input supplies).
● Tax Calculation Method:
● Tax on Output: Calculate tax on the selling price at applicable GST rates.
● Tax on Input: Deduct input tax credit (ITC) from the output tax payable.
● GST Calculation Formula:
● GST Payable = Output GST - Input GST
Under VAT (Value Added Tax):
● VAT Calculation:
● Tax is levied at each stage of production and distribution.
● Tax is calculated on the value added at each stage of the supply chain.
● Tax Calculation Method:
● Output VAT: Calculated on the value added to the product at each stage of sale.
● Input VAT: Tax paid on purchases can be used to offset the output VAT.
● VAT Calculation Formula:
● VAT Payable = Output VAT - Input VAT
Conclusion
The implementation of GST (Goods and Services Tax) on goods and services in India has led to significant improvements in the economy. One of the primary benefits is the elimination of the cascading tax system, where taxes were levied on top of already taxed inputs, leading to inflated prices and inefficiencies in the tax system. With GST, taxes are now applied only on the value added at each stage of production and distribution, thereby reducing the tax burden on businesses and consumers.
Additionally, GST has streamlined the business process by replacing multiple indirect taxes with a single, unified tax regime. This simplification has reduced compliance burdens for businesses, as they now deal with a standardized tax system across the country. Moreover, the introduction of GST has facilitated easier movement of goods across state borders, promoting interstate trade and fostering economic growth.
Overall, the implementation of GST has contributed to the modernization and efficiency of the Indian economy, making it more competitive on the global stage.
More About Tax
- Section 115BAA-Overview
- Section 16
- Section 194P
- Section 197
- Section 10
- Form 10
- Section 194K
- Section 195
- Section 194S
- Section 194R
- Section 194Q
- Section 80M
- Section 80JJAA
- Section 80GGB
- Section 44AD
- Form 12C
- Form 10-IC
- Form 10BE
- Form 10BD
- Form 10A
- Form 10B
- All About Income Tax Clearance Certificate
- Section 206C
- Section 206AA
- Section 194O
- Section 194DA
- Section 194B
- Section 194A
- Section 80DD
- Municipal Bonds
- Form 20A
- Form 10BB
- Section 80QQB
- Section 80P
- Section 80IA
- Section 80EEB
- Section 44AE
- GSTR 5A
- GSTR-5
- GSTR 11
- GST ITC 04 Form
- Form CMP-08
- GSTR 10
- GSTR 9A
- GSTR 8
- GSTR 7
- GSTR 6
- GSTR 4
- GSTR 9
- GSTR 3B
- GSTR 1
- Section 80TTB
- Section 80E
- Section 80D Of Income Tax Act
- Form 27EQ
- Form 24Q
- Form 10IE
- Section 10(10D)
- Form 3CEB
- Section 44AB
- Form 3CA
- ITR 4
- ITR 3
- Form 12BB
- Form 3CB
- Form 27A
- Section 194M
- Form 27Q
- Form 16B
- Form 16A
- Section 194LA
- Section 80GGC
- Section 80GGA
- Form 26QC
- Form 16C
- Section 1941B
- Section 194IA
- Section 194D
- Section 192A
- Section 192
- Supply without consideration under GST
- List of Goods & Services Exempt Under GST
- How to Pay GST Online?
- GST Impact on Mutual Funds
- Documents Required for GST Registration
- How to Deposit Self Assessment Tax Online?
- How to Get Income Tax Return Copy Online?
- How can traders avoid income tax Notices?
- Income Tax Return Filing For Futures And Options
- Income Tax Return (ITR) for Mutual Funds
- What Are Tax Benefits on Gold Loan
- Payroll Tax
- Income Tax for Freelancers
- Tax Saving Tips for Entrepreneurs
- Tax Base
- 5 Heads of Income Tax
- Income Tax Exemptions for Salaried Employees
- How to Deal with Income Tax Notice
- Income Tax For Beginners
- How to save tax in India
- What Taxes Has GST Replaced?
- How to Register for GST India Online
- How to File GST Returns for Multiple GSTINs
- Suspension of GST registration
- GST vs Income Tax
- What Is HSN Code
- GST Composition Scheme
- History of GST in India
- Difference Between GST and VAT
- What is Nil ITR Filing and How to File It?
- How to File ITR for Freelancer
- 10 Tips for First-time Taxpayers While Filing for ITR
- Tax Saving Options Other Than Section 80C
- Tax Benefits of Loans in India
- Tax Benefit on Home Loan
- Last minute Tax Filing Tips
- Income Tax Slab for Women
- Tax Deducted at Source (TDS) under Goods and Service Tax
- GST Interstate vs GST Intrastate
- What is GSTIN?
- What is Amnesty Scheme for GST
- Eligibility for GST
- What is Tax Loss Harvesting?
- Progressive Tax
- Tax Write Off
- Consumption Tax
- How to Pay Off Debt Faster
- What is Withholding Tax?
- Tax Avoidance
- What is Marginal Tax Rate?
- Tax to GDP Ratio
- What is Non Tax Revenue?
- Tax Benefits From Equity Investment
- What is Form 61A?
- What is Form 49B?
- What is Form 26Q?
- What is Form 15CB?
- What is Form 15CA?
- What is Form 10F?
- What is Form 10E in Income Tax?
- What is Form 10BA?
- What is Form 3CD?
- Wealth tax
- Input Tax Credit (ITC) under GST
- SGST – State Goods and Service Tax
- What are Payroll Taxes?
- ITR 1 vs ITR 2
- 15h Form
- Excise Duty on Petrol and Diesel
- GST on Rent
- Late Fees and Interest on GST Return
- Corporate Tax
- Depreciation under Income Tax Act
- Reverse Charge Mechanism (RCM)
- General Anti-Avoidance Rule (GAAR)
- Difference Between Tax Evasion and Tax Avoidance
- Excise Duty
- CGST - Central Goods and Services Tax
- Tax Evasion
- Residential Status Under the Income Tax Act
- 80EEA Income Tax
- GST on Cement
- What is Patta Chitta
- Payment of Gratuity Act 1972
- Integrated Goods and Services Tax (IGST)
- What Is TCS Tax?
- What Is Dearness Allowance?
- What Is TAN?
- What Are TDS Traces?
- Income Tax for NRI
- ITR Filing Last Date FY 2022-23 (AY 2023-24)
- Difference Between TDS and TCS
- Difference Between Direct Tax vs Indirect Tax
- GST Refund Process
- GST Invoice
- GST compliance
- Income Tax Rebate under Section 87A
- Section 44ADA
- Tax Saving FD
- Section 80CCC
- What Is Section 194I?
- GST On Restaurants
- Advantages and Disadvantages of GST
- Cess on Income Tax
- Standard Deduction Under Section 16 IA
- Capital Gain Tax on Property
- Section 186 Of the Companies Act 2013
- Section 185 Of the Companies Act 2013
- Section 115 BAC of the Income Tax Act
- GSTR 9C
- What is Memorandum of Association?
- 80ccd of Income Tax Act
- Types of Taxes in India
- GST on Gold
- GST Slab Rates 2023
- What is Leave Travel Allowance (LTA)?
- GST on Car
- Section 12A
- Self Assessment Tax
- GSTR 2B
- GSTR 2A
- GST on Mobile Phones
- Difference Between Assessment year and Financial year
- How to Check Income Tax Refund Status
- What Is Voluntary Provident Fund?
- What Is Perquisites
- What Is Conveyance Allowance?
- Section 80DDB Of Income Tax Act
- What is Agriculture Income?
- Section 80u
- Section 80gg
- 194n TDS
- What is 194c
- 50 30 20 rule
- 194h TDS
- What is Gross Salary?
- Old vs New Tax Regime
- What Is Short Term Capital Gains Tax?
- What Is 80TTA Deduction?
- Income Tax Slab 2023
- Form 26AS - How to Download Form 26AS
- Income Tax Slab for Senior Citizens: FY 2023-24 (AY 2024-25)
- What is a Financial Year?
- Deferred Tax
- Section 80G - Donations Eligible Under Section 80G
- Section 80EE- Income Tax Deduction for Interest on Home Loan
- Form 26QB: TDS on Sale of Property
- Section 194J - TDS for Professional or Technical Services
- Section 194H – TDS on Commission and Brokerage
- How to Check TDS Refund Status?
- Securities Transaction Tax
- How To Save Tax In India Without Investment?
- What is Indirect Tax?
- What is a Fiscal Deficit?
- What is Debt-to-Equity (D/E) Ratio?
- What is Reverse Repo Rate?
- What is Repo Rate?
- What is Professional Tax?
- What are Capital Gains?
- What is Direct Tax?
- What is Form 16?
- What is TDS? Read More
Disclaimer: Investment in securities market are subject to market risks, read all the related documents carefully before investing. For detailed disclaimer please Click here.
Frequently Asked Questions
Value-Added Tax (VAT) is a tax imposed on the sale of goods and services to consumers. It plays a crucial role in a country's Gross Domestic Product