SEBI insists preferential offers need independent valuation

PNB Housing - SEBI

Last Updated: Dec 13, 2022 - 04:25 pm 58.2k Views
Listen icon

In the last two months, the proposed Rs.4,000 crore preferential offer by PNB Housing to Carlyle has become the bone of contention. The first objection to the deal came from proxy firm SES. Shareholder Empowerment Firm (SES) is run by former SEBI ED, J N Gupta. SES expressed reservations about the preferential offer in that there was no independent valuation done, was priced at discount to book value and did not factor control premium. The legal stand-off began with SEBI asking PNB Housing to withhold the EGM vote and PNB Housing, in turn, approaching SAT.

SAT has heard the arguments of SEBI and PNB Housing but reserved its final judgment. Meanwhile, in an interesting development, SEBI has insisted that all preferential allotments of shares pre-suppose an independent valuation. In the PNB Housing case, SEBI insisted that since the Articles of Association mandate an independent valuation for such deals, it should have been done. PNB Housing has argued that since ICDR rules do not stipulate independent valuations for listed companies, they had done the preferential allotment to Carlyle based on ICDR formula.

Also Read: SEBI halts PNB housing - Carlyle deal

The latest clarification from SEBI makes some interesting points. Firstly, ICDR is only a guide to determine minimum price and not a formula for valuation. Secondly, SEBI has also underlined that in all such cases, the only guiding factor should be minority shareholders getting a fair and just price. Lastly, SEBI pointed out that since the PNB Housing case resulted in change of control, an independent valuation should have been done by PNB Housing. The last word is yet to be said, but it could have implications for LIC Housing, Barbeque nation and a host of other proposed preferential allotments.

How do you rate this blog?

Start Investing in 5 mins*

Rs. 20 Flat Per Order | 0% Brokerage


About the Author

Open Free Demat Account
Resend OTP
Please Enter OTP
Mobile No. belongs to

By proceeding, you agree to the T&C.

Latest Blogs
Weekly Market Outlook for 4th March to 8th March

In the week gone by, Nifty traded with higher volatility as the index corrected during mid-week upto 21860, but it then witnessed a smart recovery to register new record high and the index ended the week just below 22400 with weekly gains of three-fourth of a percent.

Best EV Stocks in India 2024

As India shifts to a greener future, the electrically powered cars and trucks market will rise significantly in 2024. This article investigates the best EV stocks in India, highlighting firms leading the way in innovation, sustainability, and market capitalization.

Best Banks in India 2024

Navigating the many options for banking services becomes a crucial task for both individuals and enterprises as we enter the Indian financial scene in 2024. The top banks in India provide a wide range of services that extend beyond traditional banking, serving as cornerstones of the country's financial stability. These best banks in India offer individualized client care and state-of-the-art digital solutions that reflect the changing needs of the financial industry.